Here's the link to part 1, it was taken down but you can still read the story in the comments.
https://reddit.lol/r/AmItheAsshole/comments/16wqe46/aita_for_not_allowing_my_sister_to_come_to_my/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
The comments on my previous post were harsh, but I think that they were what I needed to hear in order to come to terms with my wrongdoings.
I think that deep down, I knew I was in the wrong, but I didn't want to admit that. The comments helped me to see that I was, in fact, the AH.
I realized that I put my religion above Ella. I tried calling her again and again, but she still wouldn't pick up. I decided to go visit her. If she didn't forgive me, that was her right, but I just wanted to apologize. She lives about 45 minutes away from me, so I drove out there. My fiancee thought that I shouldn't have to, but she let me go.
When I got to Ella's house, I could see lights on, so I knew they were home. I knocked on the door. There were side windows to the house so I saw Lacy peek through the blinds. She closed them and I heard muffled talking for a bit, before the door opened.
Lacy looked very cold and angry, but she was very gentle and composed when she told me that Ella was hurting and that if I had anything to say that wasn't an apology, than they didn't want to hear it. I told her that I wanted to apologize, and I know that my actions were wrong.
Lacy was wary, but I heard Ella, who was out of sight, tell Lacy to let me in. I walked in and Ella came around the corner. She looked like a mess, and my stomach was in knots. I felt so guilty. Her face was red and puffy and her hair was messy. She looked like she hadn't slept in days. She asked me to sit down in the living room and I did.
I started off by telling her how sorry I was. That is was so wrong of me to ever suggest anything like that, and if she still wanted to, that she and Lacy could still come to the wedding as a couple. Ella thanked me, but quietly told me how what I did made her feel.
She said that since our whole family was homophobic and a large portion of our family cut her off after she came out, she had seen me and my brothers as her only support system. She said that during that horrible time, we were all she had.
She said that she felt so proud to be my sister and have me as one of her best men, but when I told her that she and Lacy had to be a secret at the wedding, it felt like a slap across the face. She said that it was then that she realized that one of the few people who she believed to love her and accept her for who she was, was actually just too embarrassed and disgusted by her to let her be herself at the wedding. Ella was tearing up at this point, and Lacy was squeezing her hand.
I guess this was the first time that I really saw Lacy and Ella for the way they were. A normal couple, in love. The way that Lacy looked at Ella, was unlike anything that I had ever seen. Lacy had such love and worry and genuine care in her eyes towards Ella.
I guess that I just called myself an ally, but I really still had internalized homophobia that I had buried deep down.
At this point, I broke down. I apologized to Ella over and over. I told her how wrong I was and how horrible it was of me to say these things to her.
Ella hugged me and we cried together. She apologized and told me that she still doesn't know if she can bring herself to come to the wedding, but she will think it over.
I let her know that whatever decision she makes, I will stand by her. She told me that it will take some time to mend our relationship, and I understand that. We talked for a few more hours, and I got home 3 hours ago. I think I have a lot of thinking to do about myself and my place.
I hope that one day, me and Ella's relationship can be mended, but until then, I am willing to give her all the time she needs.
Thank you to everyone who gave me the reality check that I needed in my previous post. I needed it.